Nightcap Brownies

Do you ever find yourself up in the middle of the night, tossing all work aside to mix up something delicious in the kitchen in a last-ditch effort to put a nice end to a stress-filled day and (hopefully) get some sleep? …No? Well, it seems to be happening to me more often these days, haha. On one particular night I just couldn’t take it anymore; I abandoned my desk, went down to the kitchen, and began making these brownies. I knew I needed something rich. Something sinfully chocolaty. Something strongly alcoholic.

Unfortunately (at least in times like these) I can’t drink without taking some time off work first. I’m on-call 24/7 and need to be sober enough to drive at any time. That bottle of Irish cream was screaming at me from the top of the fridge, though, so – on a whim – I dumped a generous amount of the liquor in my bowl to mix with the melted butter. I should mention that I’ve only ever baked with liquor once before and so I really have no idea if this was the appropriate time to add it, but who cares? In times like these you need a fix and fast. About 5 minutes later my hands went out of control again and before I knew it…

…yeah, those Ghirardelli jumbo chocolate chunks are not in the source recipe either. I’m pretty sure I dumped in nearly the entire bag, having only used half a cup for a previous recipe. I’m telling you, it was one of those nights…

Nightcap Brownies (adapted from The Wednesday Chef’s “The Best Brownies“)


1   stick (8 T) unsalted butter

1/3   C   Irish cream liquor

1      C   sugar

¾    C   unsweetened cocoa powder

¼    t   salt

½    t   vanilla extract

2   large eggs, cold

½    C   AP flour

2     C   chocolate chunks or chips


  1. In a double boiler (or heat-proof bowl fitted snugly over a saucepan with about an inch of gently boiling water) melt butter with Irish cream, then add cocoa powder, sugar, and salt. Continue melting until mix is smooth and warm enough that you cannot dip your figure in it for longer than a few seconds (yes, I use this as excuse to “test” my batter far more often than is appropriate). The batter will have pulled together and perhaps look a little slimy due to the alcohol, but don’t worry. Set bowl aside to allow the mixture to cool.
  2. Position an oven rack to the bottom third of oven, preheat the oven to 325°F, and line an 8- or 9″-square baking dish with parchment paper. When the batter has cooled to the point where it is warm, but no longer hot, add the vanilla and then eggs – one at a time – stirring vigorously after each. When the batter looks shiny and homogeneous add the flour, stirring only until you cannot see it any longer. At this point, beat as strongly as you can with your wooden spoon or spatula – work out that stress!! – for exactly 40 strokes. Trust me, this is magic; Luisa knows her stuff.
  3. Add chocolate chunks, fold into batter, and spread the batter evenly into the prepared pan. Bake until a toothpick test shows only a slight amount of moist batter (not wet) when removed. The source recipe estimates 20-25 minutes. The numerous times I’ve baked the recipe exactly according to instructions it has taken my oven about 30 minutes and with the Nightcap variation it took about 35. These are heavy brownies, baby! Patience.
  4. When brownies have finished, remove from oven and let dish cool on a wire rack. Cut and serve warm (about 15 minutes of cooling) for “lava cake” – like dessert. Cut and serve completely cooled for a thick, fudge-like brownie.

Beezer’s Notes:

These brownies were exactly what I needed that night: ungodly rich, delicious, not-to-sweet, and spiked with lovely – appropriately non-intoxicating – Irish cream. I didn’t anticipate the lava-cake-like consistency of the warm serving, but it was a wonderful surprise. I only wish I had had some vanilla ice cream to go along side. The best thing about this spontaneous midnight kitchen adventure: I was able to go to bed relaxed and sated.

The next morning I cut another brownie for breakfast (pssht, like you’ve never eaten dessert for breakfast…) and got another surprise: the Nightcap variation produced much denser brownie squares that the original recipe. Now, the original recipe is pretty dense (which is why it is my favorite, by the way) so I hadn’t thought a denser brownie was possible, but the cooled Irish cream-infused, chocolate chunk – laden brownies bordered on fudge! Again, no complaints here, and I really enjoy how I have almost two entirely different desserts in a single recipe: serve warm and you have a cake-like brownie filled with melted chocolate, serve cool and you’re biting into a thick fudge-y bar of mixed chocolate – and both with an Irish cream twist! Win, win in my opinion. Let me know what you think!

Overall Enjoyment: ♥   ♥   ♥   ♥

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: